Question from a Reader:
Why is there criticism of Watanabe Nagisa for smiling after she accused Nakai Masahiro of sexual violence? On social media, I see comments like “She looks fine, so it must be a lie” or “If she can release a photobook, she can’t have PTSD.” I believe it is unreasonable to condemn someone who has suffered from sexual
violence for trying to move forward with their life. Mental health issues such as PTSD, panic disorder, and Meniere’s disease are not visible. Even though she is making efforts toward reintegration and independence, those who dismiss her experience as “lies” or “self-promotion” are imposing limits on the victim’s life. It takes immense courage for a woman who has experienced sexual violence to come forward. I feel that the prevailing attitude of blaming her for “making too much noise” or “seeking social sanctions” is more harmful to society. Just because Watanabe Nagisa appears cheerful does not mean her past trauma has disappeared. The ways in which individuals suffer and recover are unique to each person, and no one has the right to deny that. What do you all think?
Accusations of Sexual Violence and Society’s Response
Recently, there has been a plethora of opinions regarding Watanabe Nagisa’s accusation against Nakai Masahiro for sexual violence. The criticism of her smiling is particularly prominent, and I find this truly unreasonable. Her courageous act of coming forward must not have been easy.
Invisible Suffering
Mental health issues such as PTSD, panic disorder, and Meniere’s disease are not visible from the outside. Therefore, no matter how healthy she may seem, her past suffering has not vanished. Those who label her efforts toward independence and reintegration as “lies” or “self-promotion” must reflect on what they are thinking. I feel that the societal trend of pressuring victims only exacerbates the issue. As someone studying law, I strongly believe that understanding these issues is essential. The law should be there to protect victims, and it should support individuals with the courage to speak out, like her.
The Impact of Social Media
Social media can also reveal the ugly side of society. Recently, I was shocked to hear conspiracy-like theories about Watanabe’s activities during a conversation with a friend. It was a moment that made me feel the low awareness of human rights. In response to this situation, I believe my role is to support victims. I feel that by purchasing her photobook or joining her membership, I can provide even a small amount of support. Of course, there are individuals with extreme opinions online, but most people empathize with her suffering and wish for her to live happily. There is a need to combat malicious slander with the power of the law.
In Conclusion
I think everyone has their own feelings about this issue. What we can do is to accept and support the voices of victims unconditionally. What do you think? I would be happy if you could share your own experiences and thoughts in the comments.
