Which is More Enjoyable for Tourism: Hakodate or Asahikawa in Hokkaido?
Hokkaido is Japan’s northernmost island, known for its stunning natural landscapes, hot springs, and vibrant culture. Among its many cities, Hakodate and Asahikawa stand out as popular tourist destinations,
each offering unique charms and experiences. If you’re planning a trip to Hokkaido, you may be wondering which city is more enjoyable for tourism. This guide will provide a comprehensive comparison of Hakodate and Asahikawa, including practical logistics, cultural insights, insider tips, and everything else you need to plan your visit.
Overview of Hakodate and Asahikawa
Before diving into the details, let’s briefly overview the two cities: – Hakodate: Located in the southern part of Hokkaido, Hakodate is known for its picturesque harbor, historical sites, and delicious seafood. The city has a rich history influenced by Western culture due to its role as one of Japan’s first port cities opened to foreign trade in the late 19th century. – Asahikawa: Situated in the central part of Hokkaido, Asahikawa is the second-largest city on the island. It is renowned for its proximity to nature, including Asahiyama Zoo and the stunning Daisetsuzan National Park. Asahikawa is considered a hub for outdoor activities and winter sports, making it appealing to those who enjoy nature and adventure. Now that you have a brief understanding of each city, let’s delve into the aspects that make each one appealing for tourists.
Practical Logistics
When planning your trip to either Hakodate or Asahikawa, consider the logistics involved.
Transportation
– Getting to Hakodate: 1. By Air: Hakodate Airport connects with major cities such as Tokyo and Osaka. The flight takes approximately 1.5 hours from Tokyo. 2. By Train: The shinkansen (bullet train) from Tokyo to Hakodate takes about 4 hours. If you’re coming from Sapporo, the limited express train takes around 3 to 4 hours. 3. By Bus: Highway buses connect Hakodate with other major cities, but this option is slower and less comfortable. – Getting to Asahikawa: 1. By Air: Asahikawa Airport also connects with Tokyo, but flights might be less frequent than those to Hakodate. 2. By Train: Shinkansen services from Tokyo to Asahikawa are available, taking around 5 hours. The limited express from Sapporo takes approximately 1.5 hours. 3. By Bus: Similar to Hakodate, highway buses are available but are not the most convenient option.
Accommodation
Both cities offer a range of accommodations from budget hostels to high-end hotels. – In Hakodate, consider staying near the bay area for picturesque views and easy access to the morning market. Recommended hotels include: – La Vista Hakodate Bay (mid-range, views) – Hakodate Onuma Tsuruga Resort (luxury, onsen) – In Asahikawa, the city center has a variety of options, including: – Asahikawa Grand Hotel (mid-range, conveniently located) – Hotel Park Hills (budget-friendly, good access to attractions)
Cultural Insights
Understanding local culture can enhance your travel experience significantly.
Hakodate’s Cultural Highlights
– Historical Significance: Visit the fortifications of Goryokaku, a star-shaped fortress that played a pivotal role in Japan’s modernization during the Meiji Restoration. The Goryokaku Tower offers panoramic views. – Morning Market: The Hakodate Morning Market is a must-visit for seafood lovers. Try the fresh crab and uni (sea urchin) while mingling with locals. – Night Views: The view from Mount Hakodate at night is often ranked among the top three nighttime views in Japan. Make sure to go at sunset for the best experience.
Asahikawa’s Cultural Highlights
– Asahiyama Zoo: Known for its innovative animal exhibits, the zoo allows visitors to observe animals in habitats that mimic their natural environments. Don’t miss the penguin walk! – Skiing: Asahikawa is close to popular ski resorts like Kamui Ski Links, attracting snow enthusiasts from around the world. – Local Crafts: Explore the local handicrafts, particularly Asahikawa furniture, known for its quality and craftsmanship.
Insider Tips
– Local Cuisine: In Hakodate, don’t miss out on the local specialty known as ‘Ika Meshi’ (squid rice), where squid is stuffed with rice and steamed. In Asahikawa, try ‘Asahikawa Ramen,’ famous for its soy sauce broth and flat noodles. – Free Activities: Both cities offer free activities, such as walking along the historic streets of Motomachi in Hakodate or visiting the Asahikawa River for a picturesque stroll. – Public Transportation: While both cities have good public transport, Hakodate’s tram system is more extensive. Consider purchasing a day pass to save on transportation costs.
Budget Considerations
– Cost Breakdown: – Accommodation: Budget hotels start at around 3,000 JPY per night, while mid-range hotels can range from 8,000 to 15,000 JPY. – Food: Meals at local restaurants can cost between 1,000 and 2,500 JPY. Fine dining experiences may exceed 5,000 JPY. – Transportation: Budget approximately 1,500 JPY for daily transportation in either city. The shinkansen can cost around 20,000 JPY one way from Tokyo. – Local Experiences: Visiting temples, parks, and public markets is usually free or very low-cost, allowing you to manage your budget effectively.
Timing Recommendations
The best time to visit Hokkaido depends on your interests: – Winter (December to February): Ideal for snow sports and enjoying winter festivals. Asahikawa is particularly lively during this season with its winter events. – Spring (March to May): Cherry blossoms bloom in late April to early May. Hakodate is famous for its cherry blossom festivals. – Summer (June to August): Enjoy outdoor activities and beautiful landscapes. Both cities have cool summers, making them ideal for hiking. – Autumn (September to November): Experience the stunning autumn foliage, especially in Daisetsuzan National Park near Asahikawa.
Alternative Options
If you have more time or want to explore beyond Hakodate and Asahikawa, consider these alternatives: – Noboribetsu: Famous for its hot springs and hell valley, it offers a relaxing retreat and is easily accessible from both cities. – Furano: Known for lavender fields in summer, Furano provides a picturesque countryside experience.
Step-by-Step Planning Advice
1. Choose Your Base: Decide whether to base yourself in Hakodate or Asahikawa based on your interests—urban experiences or nature and adventure. 2. Book Transportation: Reserve your flights and train tickets in advance, especially during high travel seasons. 3. Select Accommodations: Look for accommodations that match your budget and preferred location. 4. Plan Activities: Research and list must-visit attractions in both cities. Consider booking tickets for popular attractions in advance. 5. Pack Accordingly: Based on the season of your visit, pack appropriate clothing. Winter gear is essential if traveling during colder months. 6. Stay Flexible: While having a plan is essential, allow time for spontaneity. Some of the best experiences come from unplanned moments.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
– Underestimating Travel Time: Distances in Hokkaido can be deceptive. Allow sufficient time for transportation between destinations. – Ignoring Local Cuisine: Skipping local dishes is a missed opportunity. Make dining a part of your cultural exploration. – Not Checking Seasonal Events: Hokkaido hosts various festivals and events throughout the year; missing these can diminish your experience.
Conclusion: Hakodate vs. Asahikawa
Ultimately, the choice between Hakodate and Asahikawa depends on the type of experience you seek. Hakodate is perfect for those drawn to historical charm, coastal scenery, and delicious seafood, while Asahikawa appeals to nature lovers and thrill-seekers who enjoy outdoor activities. Both cities offer unique attractions and cultural experiences, ensuring that your visit to Hokkaido will be memorable no matter which city you choose. By following this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to make the most of your adventure in Hokkaido, soaking in the rich culture, stunning landscapes, and unforgettable experiences that both Hakodate and Asahikawa have to offer. Happy travels!
