Thoughts on Masahiro Nakai’s Statements
Recently, I’ve been reflecting on Masahiro Nakai’s objections to the term “sexual violence.” He claims that the term is too strong and that the evidence is unclear, but there seem to be complex issues behind his statements. As someone who works in a judicial scrivener’s office, I have doubts about Nakai’s assertions from a legal
perspective. The third-party committee’s report is an investigation into Fuji Television’s response, and Nakai’s name came up not necessarily because he is the main subject. Therefore, it feels somewhat off for him to say things like “the impression of sexual violence…” or “the term is too strong.”
Request for Evidence and Confidentiality Obligations
While it’s reasonable to ask for evidence regarding the report, I find it contradictory that Nakai demands evidence while simultaneously refusing to lift his confidentiality obligations. Particularly, since the female party has lifted her confidentiality, it’s unfair for him to only seek evidence that suits his interests. This issue also cannot ignore the fact that the report is based on standards set by the WHO and the Cabinet Office. Nakai’s view that “sexual violence equals crimes with assault” seems to reflect a lack of knowledge on his part. While I can understand emotional reactions, a more rational perspective is necessary from a legal standpoint.
Neutrality and Accountability
As someone who has always projected fairness and neutrality, Nakai should accept his own situation fairly. His claims that “I can’t speak due to confidentiality” while demanding to be heard are indeed contradictory. If he didn’t want his name mentioned, he could have fulfilled his accountability from the beginning. This issue is incredibly complex, and many people hold various opinions. I also feel the need to view matters from multiple angles as a legal professional. What do you all think? When faced with such issues, how should we approach them? I would love to explore this together. Please share your thoughts and experiences in the comments. I welcome any contributions, no matter how small, so feel free to share!
