Question from a reader:
Should Japan coexist with foreigners? Should only those who have legally immigrated be accepted, or should we also consider illegal immigrants? I’m struggling with this question. Please share your thoughts on how we should approach this issue.

Reflections on Coexisting with Foreigners

Coexisting with foreigners in Japan is a very complex theme. Recently, this topic has appeared more
frequently in the news and on social media. In particular, discussions often arise regarding the treatment of those who have legally immigrated and illegal immigrants. As someone who majors in psychology and works at a judicial scrivener’s office, I have considered this issue from both legal and psychological perspectives.

Differences Between Legal Immigrants and Illegal Immigrants

First, when considering those who have legally immigrated, they are staying in Japan based on Japanese law, which guarantees them certain rights. For example, they have the right to work and access social security. They are important contributors to Japanese society and bring cultural diversity. On the other hand, illegal immigrants have limited legal protection. Since they are staying in Japan in violation of the law, they are more likely to be socially isolated and have restricted employment opportunities. Japanese law takes a strict approach towards illegal residents, forcing them to live with constant anxiety. Honestly, I think this situation is very painful. Considering that illegal immigrants are also human beings who are desperately working to support their lives, it breaks my heart.

What Does Coexistence Mean?

So, what does coexistence mean? Coexistence refers to people with different cultures and values respecting each other’s individuality and living together. Japan has been an island nation for a long time and has a unique cultural background. However, in today’s globalized world, contact with people from other countries is unavoidable. From this perspective, coexistence can no longer be seen as an option but rather as a necessity. For example, at the judicial scrivener’s office where I work, many foreign clients visit. They come to Japan for various purposes, such as buying a house or processing visa applications. Sometimes, communication can be challenging due to language barriers and cultural differences. However, I feel that it is essential to make an effort to understand each other through such experiences.

Approaches to the Issue of Illegal Immigration

It is often said that a strict approach is necessary regarding illegal immigrants. However, rather than excluding them, I believe we should first understand their situation and consider ways to support them. For instance, if there were more organizations providing legal and living assistance, it might create an environment where they can live safely. From the perspective of a judicial scrivener, it is also possible to provide support to illegal immigrants through legal procedures. Of course, there are challenging aspects from a legal standpoint, but I believe exploring ways for them to live in Japan is part of coexistence.

The Role of Legal Immigrants

Those who have legally immigrated to Japan make significant contributions to Japanese society. For example, their role as a labor force is essential, but cultural exchange is also a crucial element. The different cultures they bring introduce new perspectives and values to Japanese society. This, in turn, serves as a means for Japan to maintain its international competitiveness. Personally, I have learned a lot from my foreign friends. Their cultures and ways of thinking provide unique perspectives that are not found among Japanese people. I believe that such exchanges are the foundation of coexistence and are elements that will enrich the future of Japan.

Conclusion: Towards a Future of Coexistence

In conclusion, I believe Japan should seriously consider coexistence with foreigners. While it is natural to accept legal immigrants, we also need to have a certain level of understanding towards illegal immigrants. Instead of unilaterally excluding them, seeking ways to live together is the attitude that Japan needs moving forward. If each of us considers the significance of coexistence and takes action, we can build a better future. Coexisting with foreigners is not an easy path, but I believe that with mutual understanding and a spirit of cooperation, a way forward will surely open up. I want to continue to strive to play my part in this effort every day.