Reader’s Question:
I have a question about Madoka Magica. I think the best solution for Homura would have been to kill Sayaka after Mami’s death. If Sayaka hadn’t turned into a witch, Kyouko wouldn’t have died either. I was wondering if Homura could have covered for Sayaka’s role as a magical
girl. Wouldn’t that be better than Madoka disappearing? What do you think?
Reflecting on Homura’s Choices in Madoka Magica
So, I was chatting with a friend about Madoka Magica the other day—what a wild ride that show is, right? We got into a deep dive about Homura and her decisions throughout the series. One intriguing point that came up was whether Homura should have just eliminated Sayaka after Mami’s death to prevent the chaos that ensued later. I mean, it sounds pretty straightforward on the surface, but once you dig into the emotional layers, it gets complex. Imagine if Sayaka hadn’t turned into a witch! It could have changed the whole trajectory for everyone involved. But then, as my friend pointed out, if Homura had actually gone through with killing Sayaka, it would have pushed Madoka closer to making that fateful contract. It’s like playing chess, but with emotions and life-or-death stakes—every move has consequences. I remember feeling so torn when Sayaka was ready to go off the deep end. I mean, how many times have we seen a character spiral because of their choices? It’s gut-wrenching. And you know, that moment when Madoka almost contracts to save Sayaka? Just thinking about it gives me chills. The thought that Homura might have considered killing her friend in a desperate bid to change the future is just so heavy. And then there’s the whole thing about Kyouko getting involved. Homura’s plans seem like they just keep unraveling, and it’s almost comical in a tragic way. Like, you’re watching her try to piece together a puzzle, but every time she gets close, someone knocks the pieces off the table. It’s frustrating yet fascinating. If we were to think outside the box—what if Homura had actually tried to build alliances instead? Instead of seeing Mami as competition, she could have worked with her. I can just imagine the scene where they all team up to take down the Witch, sharing snacks and laughs while discussing strategies. I mean, why not have a little fun amidst all the chaos? Maybe throw in some of that classic manzai humor that I love so much, where the punchlines fly as fast as the action. Yeah, it’s clear that Madoka Magica isn’t just about magic and battles; it’s also about the relationships and the choices we make. It’s a poignant reminder that sometimes the hardest decisions aren’t about right or wrong, but rather the emotional ties that bind us. So, what do you think? Have you ever had a moment in a story where you felt like a character could have made a different choice? I’d love to hear your thoughts and any memorable moments that stuck with you! Share your experiences in the comments!
