Reader’s Question:
Why is it acceptable to criticize Prince Hisahito and Princess Kako, but not to criticize Princess Aiko? I would like to know the reason behind this.
Balancing Criticism and Respect
Recently, I have been reflecting on the differences in criticism directed at Prince Hisahito and Princess Kako compared to that aimed at Princess Aiko. Specifically, I’ve often heard the
opinion that criticism of Princess Aiko is unacceptable, and I’ve been curious about the reasons behind this. One day, while talking with a friend at a café, he remarked, “Princess Aiko is special.” He argued that because Her Highness could potentially become the future Empress, special consideration is necessary regarding criticism. Indeed, the position of the Emperor is a symbol of Japan and a source of support for the people. Therefore, the opinion that criticism directed at her should be approached with caution holds some validity.
The Boundary Between Public Duties and Private Life
Additionally, I believe whether one understands the public duties of the imperial family is a significant point. While the imperial family fulfills public roles, they also have personal lives. Criticism of their public duties is certainly permissible, but when that criticism extends into their private lives, it can border on defamation. For example, once you understand how much effort members of the imperial family put in, it becomes difficult to criticize lightly. Having worked part-time at a judicial scrivener’s office, I have some knowledge of the law. What I’ve learned is that criticism needs to be based on evidence. Criticism without a foundation is merely slander and can hurt someone’s feelings. Therefore, I believe it is vital to express opinions grounded in reason regarding any member of the imperial family.
In Conclusion
The notion that criticism of Princess Aiko is unacceptable likely stems from her carrying the future of the imperial family. As the future Empress, there are high expectations from the public. When criticizing her, it is crucial to understand her position and to express opinions with respect. What do you think, dear readers? I would love to hear your thoughts and experiences regarding the balance of criticism. I am eager to listen to your perspectives.
